James Hardie vs. Vinyl vs. LP SmartSide: What’s Best for Colorado Winters?

rrexteriors
5 days ago
4 min read

When choosing siding for Colorado homes, James Hardie (Fiber Cement) is the top choice for fire resistance and longevity, making it ideal for the foothills and "forever homes." LP SmartSide (Engineered Wood) offers superior impact resistance, making it the best defense against severe hail in areas like Parker and Aurora. Vinyl Siding remains the most budget-friendly, low-maintenance option, though standard grades can become brittle during Colorado’s freeze-thaw cycles.

The "False Spring" and the 60-Degree Swing

If you’ve lived in Colorado for more than a year, you know the drill. It’s January. You wake up and it’s -5°F. You scrape the ice off your windshield, cursing the wind. By 2:00 PM? It’s 65°F, the sun is blazing, and you’re in a t-shirt.

We call it "False Spring," and while we love it, your house hates it.

That rapid temperature swing causes materials to expand and contract violently. Add in our high-altitude UV rays (which burn paint faster than anywhere else in the country) and the inevitable "Parker Pockmarking" hail storms, and you realize that siding in Colorado has a tough job.

At Rocky Ridge Exteriors, we aren’t married to one manufacturer. We install them all. That means we don’t have to "sell" you on one specific product. We just want you to know exactly how each one handles a Colorado winter so you can make the right choice for your wallet and your peace of mind.

Vinyl Siding (The Budget-Friendly Contender)

Let’s be real—vinyl gets a bad rap sometimes, and it’s not always fair. Modern, premium vinyl is a far cry from the cheap plastic stuff you saw on houses in the 90s. It is affordable, it comes in a million colors, and the best part? You never have to paint it. Ever.

The Colorado Reality: Here is the transparent truth. Vinyl is plastic (PVC). When plastic gets cold—like "2 AM in February" cold—it gets brittle. If a stray baseball or a shovel hits standard vinyl when it’s freezing, it can crack.

Also, remember those temperature swings? Vinyl expands and contracts more than any other material. If it’s nailed on too tight (which many inexperienced installers do), it will buckle and warp when the sun hits it.

Best For: Rental properties, budget-conscious renovations, and house flips.
The Rocky Ridge Verdict: If you choose vinyl, don't buy the cheapest grade. We install premium vinyl with insulated backing that helps it hold its shape against the wind and cold.

James Hardie Fiber Cement (The "Forever Home" Choice)

You’ll hear contractors talk about "Hardie Board" like it’s the holy grail. There’s a reason for that. James Hardie isn’t wood or plastic; it’s a composite made of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers.

The Colorado Reality: This stuff is heavy, and it is tough. Because we are in "HardieZone 5," the boards we install are specifically engineered for freezing wet climates.

But the biggest selling point for our friends in the foothills (Castle Pines, Larkspur, Perry Park) is Fire Resistance. James Hardie is non-combustible. It will not melt like vinyl and it will not burn like wood. If you are worried about wildfire risk, this is the gold standard.

Pros: Fire resistant, rot-proof, woodpecker-proof (they can’t drill into cement!), and comes with a 30-year non-prorated warranty.
Cons: It is the most expensive option to install because it requires specialized tools and labor. It can also be brittle if hit by a massive hail stone, but it takes a lot to break it.
The Rocky Ridge Verdict: If this is your "forever home" and you want the highest ROI and safety, Hardie is the winner.

LP SmartSide (The Hail Warrior)

LP SmartSide is "Engineered Wood." That means they take wood strands, coat them in waxes and zinc borate (to stop rot and termites), and compress them under insane pressure.

The Colorado Reality: If you live in "Hail Alley" (looking at you, Aurora and Parker - the Springs don't have the best track record either...), LP SmartSide is a beast. Because it is wood-based, it has a little bit of "bounce." When a golf-ball-sized hailstone hits fiber cement, it might crack. When it hits LP, it usually bounces off without leaving a dent.

It also looks the most like real wood because... well, it is wood. It has a deep cedar grain texture that adds incredible curb appeal.

Pros: Incredible impact resistance (Hail resistant), easier and faster to install than Hardie, excellent 50-year warranty (though it is prorated after the first few years).
Cons: It is combustible (though treated). It will eventually need to be painted, usually every 10-15 years, to keep moisture out.
The Rocky Ridge Verdict: If your biggest fear is the next hail storm destroying your siding, LP SmartSide is likely your best bet.

Who Can You Trust?

Here is the secret most contractors won't tell you: The installation matters more than the material.

You can buy the most expensive James Hardie board, but if the installer doesn't use the right flashing or nails it too tight, it will fail in a Colorado winter.

At Rocky Ridge Exteriors, we are locals. We know that the wind here doesn't just blow; it howls. We know the sun doesn't just shine; it cooks. Whether you choose Vinyl, Hardie, or LP, we install it to manufacturer specs so your warranty is valid and your home is protected.

Still not sure? Let’s look at your house together. We can bring samples of all three so you can feel the difference and see the colors in the Colorado sunlight.

Click Here to Contact Us!